[monchan]

I've only ever used a polespear and some fish are really hard to get close to, although some are easy. But I image the feeling is really different from a gun. (having never used a speargun, but looking forward to my first go in spring) You really have to be sure not to take hail mary shots, because distance is really important and you do need to get as much penetration as possible for the paralyzer to work effectively. To the point of letting some fish go. I find fish that hang out in reefs (not holed up) are fairly good or enjoyable targets (neither easy or difficult, just fun) Bigger fish that come through in small numbers or schools are harder, but a great challenge if your ready when you come across them.

But I think spearguns and spears have different purposes suited to the location you dive, and the fish you pursue.

In answer to your question. I always get good fish with my polespear, though maybe not always the fish I desired. And I don't feel like I've cheated.
So I would imagine it's the same for those who use a speargun.

Happy hunting.