[tbgsub]

if you like scratches get the D2, I have an EDY and slammed it on the corals yesterday stalking a Giant trevally and the Chrystal display is still without a scratch, which means the face is harder than the coral!! Like the D2 you can have a watch place replace the battery even though the manual stresses a certified pressure test, Cressi doesnt do it, and they endorse a standard watch battery replacement. Good luck with your choice.

I have been using my EDY for 1.7 years (warranty is about to expire and I am not worried at all), broke a strap that was replaced by a local shop from their rental supply, and I carelessly scrape it on corals (even though I try not to) twice a week and I can't complain about its Freedive performance, this thing is a little tank! and the PC upload kit (separate purchase) is nice to use and analyze! I am a happy customer.

best of luck deciding.

TBGSUB