Thread: BCD or Wing?
View Single Post
  #2  
Old July 13th, 2008
Old Man Dave's Avatar
Old Man Dave Old Man Dave is offline
Forum Mentor
 
Join Date: Feb 2005
Location: Guernsey, Channel Islands, UK.
Posts: 2,364
Rep Power: 3635
Old Man Dave moved beyondOld Man Dave moved beyondOld Man Dave moved beyondOld Man Dave moved beyondOld Man Dave moved beyondOld Man Dave moved beyondOld Man Dave moved beyondOld Man Dave moved beyondOld Man Dave moved beyondOld Man Dave moved beyondOld Man Dave moved beyond
Re: BCD or Wing?

This is going to be a personal preference thing but here's my twopence worth.

A wing was meant to simplify things as stabs have got very complex. Stabs with separate harness, inner bladder, multiple pockets, loads of D rings, back up bottle etc, etc, etc. Some reputedly have a kitchen sink.

Origanally stabs were an attempt to simplify things by combining an ABLJ with a harness. They just went a bit far. So the wing was a back to basics approach. I have tried a wing as my buddy uses one and they are okay but a bit limiting. They do their job and no more and are quite expensive for what they are. I was not keen on my all singing all dancing stab either. It was expensive and too complex for ease of use.

I now use a very simple stab. It's the sort used by dive schools. Simple shape which uses the vest as a harness and has just 2 pockets and 2 D rings. It was half the price of a "normal" stab.

Like I said, personal preference, so that's it IMHO.

Dave
__________________
DeeperBlue Mentor. Guernsey 2009 DB Shop become DB Supporter
Hall of Fame
Reply With Quote