Devin,
The best bet is to be able to try them out before buying since feet seem to come in different shapes, but of course that requires that you have friends who can loan them to you. I'm sure others will have recommendations, but I can only comment on two brands because that is all I've used.
Until last summer I was using Esclapez Blacks. They have a very comfortable foot pocket, but they are too flexible to bring you up very well from 60 feet here on the left coast where we have to wear thick wet suits and our buoyancy changes so dramatically with depth. Its not that you can't come up, but it just won't happen very fast. I have a size 10 foot and wear 44-46 fins, and you are welcome to try them out if they fit and you wish to do so.
Last summer I went to Matrix #2 blades with Picasso Black Team pockets. Matrix come standard with Dessault foot pockets, but when I tried a pair on, they were very painful on my high instep. Even though the #2 blades are toward the more flexible end of their 1-5 choices of stiffness, they give me much more thrust than the Esclapez, and I'm very happy with them.
I'm sure others will have a lot more input, but these are just the fins with which I have personal experience.