Hi, Immerlustig,
Sure, it probably is a dangerous statement regarding hypoxic training and blackout. However, I trained at a very high level as a competitive swimmer and we put the entire team through hypoxic training for years without an incident. In fact, in my entire experience over almost twenty years of intensive competitive swimming training and all levels of training from beginner up to national/international level competition and there was never a single breath/gas imbalance related injury. Never even heard of one.
I attribute this to the fundamentally aerobic nature of surface/speed swimming training.
Re: Dolphin kicking and negative pressure or exhale diving.... for the benefit of other readers, these are newer techniques that have not become "mainstream". The idea with exhale diving is that you breathup, saturate, then exhale before descending and dive on more-or-less empty lungs. One of the main officianados of this technique is Sebastian Murat. Physiologically, at least to 50meters, the technique is sound, probably even superior, but it is a radical departure from breath-hold diving as practiced by world record holders like Martin Stepanek and from the way I was trained and the way most people practice freediving.
So, in the context of negative pressure diving, I agree with you. You are probably right about anaerobic function being preferable for a performance dive.
In the context of purge, peak inhale and pack techniques, pressurized lungs, the wide amplitude dolphin kick is an effective way to distribute the load. The concept of distribution is different from exhale diving. Frankly, I don't have a lot of experience beyond 60meters and at those levels, I am not challenged by lactic build up. Of course, technically diving with careful attention to all phases of the dive make this much easier.
Lungfish