Rubber compounding very much affects fin performance and durability. Often clay was used as a filler, especially on non-black items. Carbon black strengthens rubber, that is why vehicle tyres are black, but there are also antioxidants and UV inhibitors added to rubber compounds depending on what they are to be used for. In the early days the dive equipment manufacturers were not fully on top of this and their products could go gummy, or rip or crack, hence these products could not survive for decades unless they were stored in talc and out of sunlight and even then the mechanical properties would have been lost. Modern rubber fins have a much longer life, but will succumb eventually to oxidation and reversion of the rubber. As for plastic fins, well who knows, but they are made with a much wider range of materials. The tear strength of silicone rubber is reduced, that is why fins are not made of the stuff.