• Welcome to the DeeperBlue.com Forums, the largest online community dedicated to Freediving, Scuba Diving and Spearfishing. To gain full access to the DeeperBlue.com Forums you must register for a free account. As a registered member you will be able to:

    • Join over 44,280+ fellow diving enthusiasts from around the world on this forum
    • Participate in and browse from over 516,210+ posts.
    • Communicate privately with other divers from around the world.
    • Post your own photos or view from 7,441+ user submitted images.
    • All this and much more...

    You can gain access to all this absolutely free when you register for an account, so sign up today!

Old Florida Spearo tries the frozen north

Thread Status: Hello , There was no answer in this thread for more than 60 days.
It can take a long time to get an up-to-date response or contact with relevant users.

cdavis

Well-Known Member
Jan 21, 2003
4,101
815
218
74
I’m a southern boy, warm water, so 5 or 6 mil suits are just not in my frame of reference. To me, the best wetsuit is a tee shirt. But, being terminally curious, I wanted to try some of that freezing water. Went up to Freedive-apaloosa last year and loved it, 73 degree surface, 35 degree bottom. Bizzare, but fine in a 3 mil. This year, Fondueset(Chris) invited a bunch of divers to join him in northern Michigan, water temp , high 40s or a little more. You know, balmy summer by his standards. . . . . nuts, completely nuts. But, Laminar and others were coming, so it was too good to pass up, especially since Chris let me use his 6 mil Elios (which fit perfect).

What a crew. Chris was as wonderfully twisted in person as he is when posting, excellent diver, super photographer who comes with an encyclopedic knowledge of how yoga and other eastern disciplines (of which I am totally ignorant) add to freediving. Host, guide, and general, make it happen, guy. Claire, Chris’s daughter, with whom I had dove in Little Cayman. Monofin specialist, getting into no fins. Did I say something about cold resistance? I’m in a 6 mil and she is diving the river, no suit. Laminar (Pete), massively competent, great teacher, exhale diver par excellence, source of all freediving knowledge. Also a super nice guy. I’m glad he likes to talk about freediving, cause I just about wore his ears out with questions. Alicia, godess mother who makes the way straight, kept us all going, making sure everybody had what they needed. She is a tiny little, very attractive lady with an independent streak a mile wide and an astonishing tolerance for cold water, who has led a most interesting life. The conversation was as good as the diving. Freedivers are an interesting group. How often can you get two chinese speakers in the same room?

I’m not sure how he pulled it off, but Chris arranged quite a reception for me. He had warned me that the weather was "changable". Here is how it went. Arrive at the hotel, weather is beautiful, suit up in the hotel room, picture window overlooking the lake (very up town diving), walk out to the car. There is a small dark cloud on the horizon. Drive 5 minutes to the spot, its even got a nice parking lot. Now the sky is dark and threatening, thunder in the distance. Walk 50 paces to the water. Now its sheet lightning and a big, black, nasty squall line is coming fast. Hmm, maybe this is not such a good time to get in the water. BOOM. Lightning, pretty close. Back to the car. By the time we got back to the parking lot, the temp has dropped 30 degrees and it’s sleeting, which quickly turned into small hail. I’m standing there in 6 mil armor, agog at stuff I’d never seen before as the hail got bigger, coming down so thick it started to cover the ground, bouncing off cars and up 6-8-10 feet. The sound is a deafening, a staccato series of bangs, like being inside a steel barrel as a hundred soccer players threw rocks at it. . The hail kept getting bigger, soon the size of grapes and started to HURT! Into the car, quick! What a scene. 3 minutes later, all stops, the sun starts to come out, the temp goes back up and it was a summer day again, except for the piles of hail stones. We walk back down and get in the water, It almost seemed normal to see hailstones still floating in the water around us. . . . . . "Changeable" he wasn’t kidding!

I got in the water wearing 1mil shorts under a 3 mil vest under 5 mil Elios bottoms under a 6 mil Elios top. If I’m counting right, that’s 15 mils on my mid section. I was almost instantly cold when I hit the water, face on fire which quickly turned so numb I could not hold the snorkel properly and was leaking water like crazy. Starting to shiver in less than an hour. You know, freediving has a lot of parts. The basics are pretty much the same no matter what kind of diving you do, but those basics go together in subtly different ways and I could not get them to fit. Wearing enough lead for 6 divers in Florida, floating like a cork in a straight jacket, can hardly get off the surface, can’t get my co2 level down, no dive reflex, can’t balance underwater, coming back to the surface, breaching like an out of control whale after 30 seconds at 6 meters, lungs screaming for air. I’d long since forgotten how difficult it is to be a newbie. Respect to all you new divers.

Well, what was the diving like? Very pretty and mostly low key, shallow. Vis was less than perfect (it had been raining a lot) but still nice, 30-40 ft. ,most places. At times the water acquired a vivid electric blue that looked like the Caribbean, very good stuff. The diving was around rock break walls, little wreaks, big pipelines and a river mouth, which was a surprise and turned out to be a quite a place. The vis was poor in the river flow, maybe 6-8 ft, but the fish were wild. Big schools of all kinds of fairly large, eating size, fish. Drum, several species of suckers, muskie, walleye, carp, even a salmon, etc etc, 12 species, all milling around in a small area. Do a drift through them and you felt like you were lying down in the middle of an 8 lane highway at night with a zillion cars going by, no lights. The fish would run over you, so close you could touch them. The water warmed up a little as the week went on and the jetties became full of life, especially schools of suckers (just like goatfish for all you tropical types.) You want to perfect your spearfishing body language? Try sneaking up inside a school of suckers. They are so spooky, the school will bolt if your hand moves too fast from 30 feet away. My skills were rusty, but came back fast. Very fun.

By the last day, I felt like it was coming together. Still wearing a ridiculous amount of rubber, but comfortable and warm, with exhale dives approaching the times I do in warm water. Did just enough depth to know for sure that the 30 m recreational dives we do in the Bahamas would not be fun in a 6 mil, assuming I could even do it. Suddenly acquiring a 50 lb anchor after passing neutral buoyancy is an interesting experience. I’ll give you this on cold water depth, the trip down is FAST. Hats off to all you deep divers in cold water.

A very fun trip. My sincere thanks to all who made it possible.

Connor
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: agbiv and Jon
Glad you had a good time up in the northern regions Connor! Good stuff.
 
Connor, Awesome to have you here - backatcha from all concerned on the complements.
The Hail-storm was special for Connor - truly a one-off. When we finally dove for the cars a chunk of hail hit my index finger as I closed the door - I still have a lump and bruise!

After Video analysis here is a comprehensive list of species we saw at the River mouth - By the way - running the current in a monofin was fiercely good fun!
FYI FYI - Checking out the river mouth for fish was Connor's call!

Giant mutant smallmouth bass
Muskie (one of two I've ever seen in the bay)
Bowfin (same as above)
Freshwater Drum (big schools of big drum - never before seen before late july)
Gizzard Shad (also big schools)
Trout Fingerlings
Salmon
White Suckers
Red Horse Suckers
Giant smoke-grey Stephen King lookin Sucker with alien eyes
Channel Catfish (never before seen!)
Sea Lamprey
Walleye ( a School of big walleye)
Carp (allways circling for the attack)

All of these were around all the time in a very small area.
Also among the ranks was Dave from Bay City - a recent PFI graduate who brought his Kayak - which the TV guy ended up using to get great shots in the water with us and all those fish. Alicia did an amazing job making sure Connor got enough to eat.

Connor - we were out yesterday and the bay has definitely turned over - where it was 47F when you got here - it was 61-63. Claire dove with her hood down and no gloves and the rock bass explosion is under way where you did your sucker stalking.

It was great fun watching Connor acclimate - that first day he used my elios 5 mil top - which has nylon out and is not the best in cold air. He switched to the 6 mill smooth out and did great - able to use his face again after only one day!
Pics to follow

Fav Quote from Connor (after the Hailstorm - italics indicate Florida Accent): "Now we gotta go divin' "
 
Last edited:
Here are a few images - in no particular order - me trying to look intelligent and reasonable during an on site interview for local TV and the PBS show 'Michigan Out of Doors'. A dramatic Carp shot by Pete. Connor Stalking the very elusive juvenile suckers.Pete bravely checking out an alien visitor. Sri Laminar AquAnanda manifesting to enlighten the masses.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: spaghetti
A few more - Pete creeping everybody out with his 'uncle skulky' imitation. A nefarious pod of carp - surveying Connor and I for signs of weakness. A visual koan involving feet and a Chen Bin monofin. Pete instructing us in looking casual while peeing in our wetsuits.
 
Last edited:
Damn Chris, I'm coming up there hoping for warmer water, and that's what I get? Bah humbug! I'm gonna start planning a trip up there so that I can check it out, even if it's just for a day or 2 while i'm visiting the fiancee and parents in Chicago. I'll let you know when I can make it up!
 
Trust me, I know how it goes. 3 days ago, it was 100 here, and it's been in the 50's since like Sunday night. This place is the weather change capital. And it had us diving in decent swells on Sunday, which I'm guessing you guys don't get too much of. That, and it'll be nice without having whitey in the back of my mind every time I hit the water. Should be stellar, dude. I can't wait!
 
great story there Connor and lovely pix Chris and all. Pete still insists on taking that "dayglo" pink snorkel everywhere I see.
 
Overall I think the trip went too well. I am vaguely suspicious, and I think Connor is clearly hidding something behind all of that colorful praise. I heard werewolves hate the cold water and have to wear 6 mil wetsuits in water that's 50 F and above; and don't you know it was a fullmoon that week!
 
Hey all, I thought I'd resurrect this With a few shots of the locals you guys just missed by a few weeks. Though the drums and big bass were in the amazing frenzy of species we found in the River Mouth.

Anyway - a few shots from the last week or so. The water is stupidly warm right now - 73F

IMG_9159.jpg

IMG_9221.jpg

IMG_9301.jpg

IMG_9373.jpg
 
  • Like
Reactions: bgill
oh beautiful....

It's astonishing to see the range of colors that one sees where you are; it was beautiful to see this in June as well...

-Alicia
 
DeeperBlue.com - The Worlds Largest Community Dedicated To Freediving, Scuba Diving and Spearfishing

ABOUT US

ISSN 1469-865X | Copyright © 1996 - 2024 deeperblue.net limited.

DeeperBlue.com is the World's Largest Community dedicated to Freediving, Scuba Diving, Ocean Advocacy and Diving Travel.

We've been dedicated to bringing you the freshest news, features and discussions from around the underwater world since 1996.

ADVERT