Perhaps a little late.... On The Big Blue vs The Freediver
Well quite frankly, I think that the deaths of Enzo and Jacques in the Big Blue made more sense compared with the death of Danai in the Freediver.
From a symbolical perspective…
Why doesn’t want Jacques compete with Enzo?
From the start of the competition it is not just that Jacques really fears Enzo as a person to compete with, but he fears for his life. It is quite obvious that Jacques ‘knows’ that the desire from Enzo to win will finally consume him. It is with this knowledge that after each confrontation with Enzo after Jacques records he seemed to act depressed. The symbolical death of Enzo and his flight down the Abyss finally potrays this consument and Enzo’s specific bond with the ocean.
Jacques himself has a different problem… He wants to be something he can’t, to be a dolphin/mermaid. This desire of him is always more important than the whole competition. Every time he is down there, his desire to find the mermaids overtake him from the wish to win the competition. This wish to meet these mermaids his finally his undoing because he loses his touch with reality.
From a practical way…
Well… It is quite clear for those who follow the forum for some time that the CMAS doesn’t like the depth discipline due of its (then believed) risks. CMAS name wasn’t only used in The Big Blue, they even had some influence in it. The ‘medical warning’ surrounding Enzo’s death is the way how the CMAS tried to give the audience the message “Don’t try this crazy sport at home, folks”.
And in the Freediver…
In the Freediver, these things doesn’t play a part of the story. Maggie Stone doesn’t dive for the sea, just to be the best. Even Enzo had a more obvious bond with the sea. And she isn’t punished for that except of by a black-out.
When Danai dies, she isn’t better off than Maggie. At a certain point she chose to follow the doctor in everything, even if she loses Hector for that. That doesn’t make her a heroine either, and her death is nothing more than a senseless waste of life.
Where is the practical / symbolical logic in that? If you want to imitate the Big Blue, you might try to insert some if the thoughts behind the actions. If in doubt, you might want to read otherwise Luc Besson’s book instead (perhaps together with Jacques Mayol book and bio).
Frankly... The Big Blue had some documentarian feeling, but is in reality a quite symbolic movie. The freediver tries to be a symbolic movie, but never get past a documentary.